tukacs.com › Guide

Guide

Broker, multiple agent, tied agent, online comparison site: who works for whom?

Adviser, tied agent, broker, salesperson, comparison portal, a bank's 'insurance expert' – through the client's eyes they are all the same: the insurance person who deals with the paperwork. Act LXXXVIII of 2014 on insurance activity (the Insurance Act, Bit.), however, draws a sharp line between them, and the classification is not a courtesy label but a legal status: it determines who acts on whose mandate, whose products they may offer, who pays them and who is answerable if they make a mistake. As a broker, I see that most clients, even after years, do not know whether the person they handle their insurance with is the insurer's person or their own – even though the intermediary must disclose this before the contract is concluded, on paper or on another durable medium. I have already written about the difference between a broker and a tied agent; here I line up the whole field, including the multiple agent (an agent representing several insurers), bank sales and the online comparison site.

In short

The two main groups in the law: tied and independent

Under the definitions in Section 4 of the Bit., a tied insurance intermediary is someone who, on the basis of a legal relationship with the insurer, distributes the products of one insurer – or the non-competing products of several insurers – (this is the tied agent), or who distributes competing products of several insurers (this is the multiple agent). An independent insurance intermediary, by contrast, is, in the words of the law, 'an insurance intermediary acting on the client's mandate' – in everyday language, a broker. A single question separates the two groups: who gives them the mandate. The tied intermediary receives it from the insurer, the independent one from the client. Everything else – the source of remuneration, liability, how many insurers' quotes they see – follows from this. So the question is not whether someone is pleasant, knowledgeable or 'independent-minded', but in which section of the supervisory register they appear; I have explained this step by step in the article on checking the register.

Tied agent and multiple agent: on the insurer's side

A tied agent offers the products of one insurer – or the non-competing products of several insurers – and naturally looks for a solution for you within that range; this is not a flaw, just a limitation worth knowing about. The multiple agent is a more complicated case, because from the outside they look like a broker: they put several insurers' quotes in front of you, compare them and 'pick the right one for you' – but, under the Bit. classification, they do so on the insurers' mandate. A multiple agent distributes the products of the insurers they have contracts with, receives their remuneration from them, and their contractual obligations also run towards them; their advice can still be good, but the set of relationships is different from that of a broker, where you are the principal. In Hungarian practice, several banks offer home insurance or credit protection insurance alongside a loan as tied intermediaries – as tied agents or multiple agents – and several network sales companies are also tied intermediaries; which of the two applies you can find out from the intermediary disclosure document. This is also where the question of liability divides: under the Bit., the principal insurer is liable for the tied agent's activity, whereas the multiple agent – like the broker – must maintain their own liability insurance. So if someone says 'I work with several insurers', that does not settle whether they are a broker: ask them on whose mandate they act.

The broker: appointed by the client

Legally, the broker relationship is a mandate: you give the mandate, and the broker acts on your mandate towards the insurers. The broker's remuneration is typically paid by the insurer in the form of commission, which is part of the insurance premium, but the direction of the mandate and of liability does not change: the broker is liable for their own professional errors, and the Bit. requires compulsory liability insurance for this. The Bit. – transposing the EU Insurance Distribution Directive (IDD) – also expects an independent intermediary to base their advice on an analysis of a sufficient number of insurance contracts available on the market; how many insurers this means in practice, and why one may be missing from the comparison, is discussed in a separate article. With me, the broker's work goes like this: needs assessment, requesting quotes from insurers, a comparable quote table with a recommendation, and then, after your decision and signature, forwarding the proposal to the insurer; in a claim, the primary route for reporting is the insurer's claims line, and if a case gets stuck or disputed, I help where I can; and I review the contract if you ask me to. There is one thing a broker does not do either: the broker is not the insurer – the insurer decides on cover and on claims under its own policy conditions.

The online comparison site: a broker or an agent – just with a screen

A comparison portal is not a separate legal status; the Bit. does not recognise an 'online intermediary'. Behind the screen stands a registered intermediary firm: the large Hungarian portals are typically brokerage firms, but there are also platforms backed by a multiple agent, and some sites are a single insurer's own web shop – the latter is not an intermediary but the insurer itself. If a brokerage firm is behind the portal, then by taking out a policy – by accepting the general terms and conditions – you give it a broker mandate, and it becomes the registered intermediary on your policy; this becomes important when you later want to appoint someone else, because insurers record one intermediary per policy. The portal's strength is a quick comparison of the price and a few cover parameters; its weakness is that you carry out the needs assessment alone when filling in the questionnaire, and the duty of disclosure – stating every material circumstance accurately – remains yours here too, together with the consequences of any mistake. In a claim, the portal's customer service is likewise not the insurer: the claim is reported to the insurer. Exactly who you are contracting with is shown in the portal's footer and legal notice – the intermediary firm's name and registration number must appear there, and you can check them on regiszter.mnb.hu.

Ancillary intermediaries and the insurer's own staff

Two further players in the field often go unnoticed. Section 4 of the Bit. recognises the person carrying out ancillary insurance intermediary activity: they distribute insurance in connection with their main business, as an add-on – for example a travel agency with travel insurance, a car dealer with a casco (comprehensive motor insurance) quote, or an electronics shop with an extended warranty. The Bit. applies simplified rules to them, the offer is typically narrowed to one product of one insurer, and the advice is limited because of the ancillary nature of the activity. The other player is the insurer's own employee, a member of its customer service or branch staff: they are not an intermediary but the insurer itself, and naturally offer their own company's products. This is not a problem either, as long as it is clear that in this case the two parties to the contract are sitting at the table, and there is no third – your appointed agent.

How can you find out in two minutes who you are dealing with?

Under Section 378 of the Bit., before the contract is concluded, the intermediary must inform you whether they act as a tied or an independent intermediary – and, if tied, on behalf of which insurer – as well as about the supervisory register and complaints handling. If you do not receive this disclosure, ask for it – if they do not provide it, that in itself is a warning sign. There are four questions worth asking anyone who offers you insurance: On whose mandate do you act? How many insurers' quotes can you put in front of me, and which ones not? Who is liable if you make a mistake – you or the insurer? What do you earn from this contract? Compare the answers with the entry on regiszter.mnb.hu: it shows the type of activity – independent intermediary, tied intermediary, tied agent, multiple agent – and the principal company. You will get answers to these questions from me too if you ask them – the Bit. disclosure rules even make their substance mandatory – and you are entitled to expect the same from the other players.

Do you have a question about which category your own intermediary belongs to?

I'll assess your needs and show you how your situation looks against several insurers – I charge no fee for the advice.

Book my appointment

Sources

Sources

This page is general information; it does not constitute professional insurance advice and is not an offer. The specific cover, exclusions and premiums are always determined by the given insurer's terms and conditions in force – it is worth going through these item by item when you request a quote. Updated: September 2026.

Further guides

Broker or agent? The difference – and why it matters

The agent represents an insurer, the broker acts on the client's instructions – it's worth knowing which one you're talking to.

Read more →

How can you check that your broker is really listed in the MNB register?

Every insurance intermediary is in the MNB's public register. Where to search, what “active” status and the principal mean, and what counts as a warning sign.

Read more →

Do you see quotes from every insurer? Who I work with, and why one may be missing

No broker sees the whole market: what the Insurance Act (Bit.) expects of independent brokers, how many insurers I work with and why one may be missing.

Read more →

If your broker makes a mistake, who is liable? Broker liability and professional indemnity insurance

Wrong advice, failure to forward, faulty data: under the Bit. the broker is liable and must hold liability insurance. What counts as an error and where to turn.

Read more →